Trick or Treat…

Please.

Please don’t.

Please don’t support UNICEF this Halloween season, or any other. If your kids are soliciting to fill those little cardboard boxes, please skip my house. We don’t and won’t ever support UNICEF. No hard feelings towards you, only UNICEF’s mission.

I grew up believing that UNICEF (the United Nations Children’s Fund, formerly the United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund, established December 11, 1946 to “meet the emergency needs of children in post-war Europe and China” and expanded in 1950 to include “the long-term needs of children and women in developing countries everywhere”) was a champion of children’s rights, safety and welfare. After adopting, I discovered otherwise.

UNICEF has been in the process of undermining international adoption for some time and they’re making great inroads.  UNICEF was a partner in “reforming” and shutting down Guatemala’s program (2008), leaving more than 3000 children in limbo.  Children who will likely never have loving, stable, and permanent families and homes.  Sorry folks, but that kinda honks me off. It hits rather close to the bone, when I consider that my son was born in Guatemala…

UNICEF’s position is that a child’s birth country and culture trump a stable, loving, and permanent home and family in any other place (adoption).  But at what cost to the child and their country’s future? I argue that UNICEF’s position has dire consequences, of which we haven’t yet begun to see. Children who live in impermanent foster care or are institutionalized until they age out and live on the streets are often without the life skills they will need or have ability to contribute to society.

Institutionalization has major repercussions (I teach classes about this very topic.). Elizabeth Bartholet, the Morris Wasserstein Public Interest Professor of Law and Faculty Director of the Child Advocacy Program (CAP) at Harvard Law School, wrote an enlightening paper on the human rights position of international adoption.  You really should read it.

This Halloween, whether you celebrate it or not, whether you have children or not, please consider the millions of children that UNICEF is turning its back on.  Leave those boxes at home…

Advertisements

7 Comments

Filed under Adoption Issues, Adoptive Mom's Perspective, Advocacy, Guatemala, International Adoption, The International Mom

7 responses to “Trick or Treat…

  1. Chris Larsen

    It is sad to know that a big organization like that would not be more helpful in aiding the plight of orphaned children. I used to support them, and am sad to learn that such things happen. I guess it just goes to show that if we want to be advocates of causes, we need to be more educated than the average bear. It not only helps you and others to promote a cause or to debunk one that is built on false, outdated or poor pretenses.
    I used to send moola to a local shelter for dogs, until someone I knew took a job there and was horrified by the cruel treatment of the animals and the deplorable conditions that they were hoarded in tiny cages, and starved. So needless to say my friend reported them, and I quit supporting them. It has been years since, and I believe those actions and others helped the shelter to turn it around so it was a help and not a hell for those innocent animals.
    Again, look, learn, listen and teach where needed but most of all…LOVE!
    My old Hippie tenets still come up Yeah Man!

  2. Thanks for the information, Judy. I had no idea. Happy Halloween to your family.

  3. Great post. Thank you for speaking to this important topic!

  4. Shawna

    Thank you for sharing. I had no idea. We have a Clifford book that shows Emily Elizabeth with a UNICEF box in her hand, which led to discussion with my three-year old daughter (who was born in China). Hmpf…I’m with ya.

  5. Thanks, Judy, for this information. I would never had known, believing as you did that UNICEF worked for the good of ALL children. In this, they are sadly misguided.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s